Our Menu

Find your new favorite dish.

Indicates a chef favorite!
Tips not included with Gift Certificates. 20% Gratuity added to parties of 6 or more.

Appetizers

Procopio's Sampler
Wings, Bosco Sticks, Jalapeño Poppers, Fried Beef Ravioli served with a side of ranch and meat sauce.

10.99

Bosco Sticks (5)
Freshly made every day. Mozzarella-filled breadsticks baked and garnished with garlic butter and parmesan cheese. Served with choice of one sauce: meat, cheese, or pizza sauce.

11.25

Breadsticks (5)
Freshly made every day! Served with one sauce: meat, cheese, or pizza sauce.
Garnished with garlic butter and parmesan cheese: 9.99

9.25

Bruschetta
Diced Tomatoes in olive oil, garlic, onions, and balsamic vinegar served with a warm baguette bread.
With fresh mozzarella: 11.75

10.25

Cheese Fries
French fries covered in mozzarella cheese and bacon. Served with a side of ranch.
Add jalapeno: 11.25

10

Garlic Cheese Bread
Sandwich bread garnished with garlic butter and sliced mozzarella cheese. Served with one sauce: meat, cheese, or pizza sauce.
Add pepperoni: 9.25

8

Pesto
Basil, pine nuts, garlic, and olive oil served with a warm baguette bread.
With fresh mozzarella: 10.50

8.50

Caprese Flatbread
Tomato, fresh mozzarella, and balsamic glaze.

8.25

Pesto Flatbread
Pesto, fresh mozzarella, and balsamic glaze.

8.25

Sun Dried Tomato Pesto Flatbread
Sun dried tomato pesto, fresh mozzarella, and balsamic glaze.

8.25

Breaded Mushrooms

10

Calamari

9.75

Chicken Tenders (5)

11.50

Fried Beef Ravioli (8)
Sun dried tomato pesto, fresh mozzarella, and balsamic glaze.

10.25

Fried Portobello Mushrooms

11.99

Jalapeno Poppers (6)

9

Meatballs & Mozzerella

12.75

Mozzerella Cheese Sticks (8)

11.99

Wings (8)
Sauces: BBQ, Sweet Chili, Buffalo, or Plain

Boneless: 10.75

Bone-in: 12.25

Salads

Salad Dressing Options

Balsamic Vinaigrette ● Blue Cheese ● Caesar ● Mullen's French ● Greek ● Homemade Italian Dressing ● Hot Bacon ● Poppy Seed ● Ranch ● Honey Mustard ● Raspberry Vinaigrette

Side Salad
Iceberg lettuce mix topped with tomatoes, cucumbers, and mozzarella cheese served with your choice of dressing.

4

Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce, parmesan, and croutons. Served with your choice of dressing.
Half size available: 4.50

7.25

Crispy Chicken Salad
Iceberg lettuce mix topped with crispy chicken tenders, tomatoes, bacon, and mozzarella cheese served with your choice of dressing. Substitute grilled chicken at no additional charge.

11.50

Greek Salad
Iceberg lettuce mix topped with red onions, cucumbers, tomatoes, blackolives, banana peppers, reta cneese, and served with Greek dressing.
Half size available: 7

11

Grilled Chicken Salad
Iceberg lettuce mix topped with croutons and grilled chicken. Served with your choice of dressing.

9.75

House Salad
Iceberg lettuce mix topped with tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, croutons and mozzarella cneese. served with your choice of dressing.
Half size available: 6.50

8.75

Sicilian Salad
Iceberg lettuce mix topped with ham, pepperoni, red onions, green olives, banana peppers, and mozzarella cheese served with our house dressing.
Half size available: 7.50

11

Spinach Salad
Baby leaf spinach topped with red onions, bacon, hard-boiled egg, croutons, and feta cheese. Served with hot bacon dressing.
*Chef recommendation: add salmon. Half size available: 7.25

10.75

Sandwiches

Sandwich Side Options

Served with chips or upgrade to:

  • french fries for $3
  • Caesar, house, or Sicilian salad for $3.50
  • Greek or spinach salad for $4
Chicken Parmesan Sandwich
Fried chicken breast topped with mozzarella cheese and meat sauce, served on a baked bun.

11.75

Ham & Cheese Sandwich
Mozzarella cheese and ham served on a baked bun.

6" 9.25

12" 11.25

Italian Sausage Cacciatore
Sausage patty, topped with mozzarella cheese, green peppers, mushroom, onion, and meat sauce, served on a baked bun.

12

Italian Sausage Sandwich
Sausage patty, topped with mozzarella cheeseand meat sauce, served on a baked bun.

11

Italian Sub Sandwich
Mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, ham, lettuce, tomato, topped with Italian dressing and servedon a baked bun.

6" 10.25

12" 12.25

Meatball Sandwich
Two meatballs served on a baked bun with mozzarella cheese.

11

Mozzarella Sandwich
Fresh mozzarella, banana peppers, tomatoes, topped with olive oil inside bruschetta breadtoasted in the oven.

11

Veal Parmesan Sandwich
Fried veal patty topped with mozzarella cheese and meat sauce, served on a baked bun.

11.50

Pasta

Traditional PastaSignature PastaStuffed PastaBaked Pasta & Parmesans
Customize Your Entrée
Add a Protein

Grilled Chicken 5.75
Grilled fresh daily

Meatballs 4.75
Meatballs either on the side or in your pasta dish

Peas 1.25
Add peas to any pasta dish or as a side dish.

Seared Salmon Fillet 7.25
Pan-seared salmon fillet. A chef favorite!

Shrimp 6.50
Shrimp cooked to order in olive oil and spices.

Gluten Free

Gluten free noodles avallable 1.

Pasta Side Options

Each entrée comes with a side salad with tomatoes, cucumbers, and mozzarella cheese along with garlic or Italian bread.

Upgrade your side salad 3.50 / 4:
Caeser 3.50 ● House 3.50 ● Sicilian 3.50 ● Greek 4 ● Spinach 4

Add your choice of protein:
Grilled Chicken 5.75 ● Seared Salmon Fillet 7.25 ● Shrimp 6.50

Traditional Pasta

Angel Hair
Meat sauce 12
Alfredo 13
Calamarata
Meat sauce 12
Alfredo 13
Farfalle
Meat sauce 12
Alfredo 13
Fettucini
Meat sauce 12
Alfredo 13
Linguini
Meat sauce 12
Alfredo 13
Spaghetti
Meat sauce 12
Alfredo 13
Penne
Meat sauce 12
Alfredo 13

Signature Dishes

Aglio Olio
Linguini or angel hair pasta tossed in a light sauce of olive oil, white wine, and crushed red pepper.

13.75

Arrabiata Pasta
Delicious creamy sauce mixed with vodka, mascarpone cheese, tomato puree, jalapenos (can be excluded if you wish) and spices, paired with angel hair pasta.

15.25

Basil Pasta
Chef Favorite! Basil chiffonade and fresh garlic simmered in roasted tomatoes and olive oil.

16

Calamarata Pasta
Italian pasta simmered in a sun dried tomato paste with our signature Alfredo sauce.

15

Linguini with Clams
Whole baby clams simmered in white wine, olive oil, garlic, and crushed red pepper.

14.75

Mediterranean Pasta
This dish has everything you could want! Clams, mussels, squid and shrimp sautéed in olive oil, white wine, garlic, and crushed red pepper.

20.25

Pasta Rosa
A blend of alfredo and meat sauce with ham and mushrooms. Let your server know if you wish to have ham and mushrooms removed.

16.75

Pesto Alfredo
Minced basil, garlic, and pine nuts add a twist to our signature Alfredo sauce.

15.75

Sicilian Pasta
Red Onion, roasted red peppers, sun-dried tomatoes, peas, mushrooms, and ham sauteed in an olive oil, white wine sauce with crushed red pepper.

17.25

Kristina's Pasta
Named after Procopio's lovely wife! Rigatoni pasta, sundried tomato strips, roasted red peppers, peas and a splash of cream.

17.25

Stuffed Pasta

Cheese Tortellini
Meat sauce 14.25
Alfredo 15.50
Meat Tortellini
Meat sauce 14.25
Alfredo 15.50
Jumbo Spinach Ravioli
Meat sauce 15.25
Alfredo 16.25
Lobster, Shrimp & Scallops Ravioli
Meat sauce 18.50
Alfredo 19.25
Beef Ravioli
Meat sauce 15
Alfredo 16.25
Portobello Mushrooms Ravioli
Meat sauce 15.5
Alfredo 16.75

Baked Pasta & Parmesans

Choose a traditional noodle or add a stuffed noodle 3.25

Baked Pasta
Meat sauce 15.50
Alfredo 16.50
Additional toppings add 1.75
Chicken Parmesan
Meat sauce 17.75
Alfredo 18.75
Eggplant Parmesan
Meat sauce 17
Alfredo 18
Lasagna
16.25
Stuffed Shells
Meat sauce 16
Alfredo 17
Veal Parmesan
Meat sauce 17.25
Alfredo 18.25

Pizzas

Procopio's Specialty Pizzas

Additional Toppings
Small 4
Medium 4.25
Large 4.75
X Large 5

Artichoke hearts, bacon, banana peppers, black olives, green olives, green pepper, ham, mushroom, onion, pepperoni, pepperoncini, sausage, spinach, tomato.

Specialty Toppings: (additional cost) anchovies, feta cheese, grilled chicken, pineapple, shrimp.

Type
Small
Medium
Large
X Large
Cheese
11.50
12.50
14.75
18.50
One Topping
12.75
13.50
16.50
19.75
Two Topping
13.50
14.50
17.50
20.50
Three Topping
13.75
15.75
18.75
21.75
Procopio's Special
Sausage, pepperoni, onions, green peppers, mushrooms
15.50
16.50
19.50
22.75
Procopio's Supreme
Sausage, pepperoni, onions, green peppers, green olives, bacon, ham, pepperoncini, mushrooms
17.50
18.50
21.50
15.50
Veggie
Tomato, pepperoncini, mushroom, onions, green olives, green peppers
16.50
17.50
19.50
22.75
Meat
Sausage, pepperoni, ham, bacon
16.25
18
19.75
22.75
Hawaiian
13.50
14.50
17.50
20.50

Stuffed Pizza

Please allow 35-40 minutes for cooking.
Additional Toppings
Small 4
Medium 4.25
Large 4.75

Artichoke hearts, bacon, banana peppers, black olives, green olives, green pepper, ham, mushroom, onion, pepperoni, pepperoncini, sausage, spinach, tomato.

Specialty Toppings: (additional cost) anchovies, feta cheese, grilled chicken, pineapple, shrimp.

Type
Small
Medium
Large
Cheese
16
18
19
One Topping
17.25
18.25
20
Two Topping
18.25
19.25
22.50
Three Topping
19.50
20.50
23.75
Procopio's Supreme
Sausage, pepperoni, onions, green peppers, green olives, bacon, ham, pepperoncini, mushrooms
22.50
23.75
26.75

Steaks

RIBEYE STEAK WITH BROCCOLI
STEAK WITH BRUSCHETTA
STEAK & SALMON PLATES
Served weekly:
Wednesday - Thursday 5pm to 8:30pm
Friday - Saturday 5pm to 9pm
Filet Mignon 6 oz
29.99
New York Strip 12 oz
31
Ribeye 10 oz
26.99
Ribeye 16 oz
35.99
Salmon 6 oz
12.99
Pork Chop 4 oz
single 9.99
double 16.99
Choice of 2 Sides
Vegetable

Ask your server about our vegetable special!

Salad

Side salad or upgrade to:
half Sicilian salad 3
half Greek salad 3.50
half spinach salad 3.50

Potato

Choice of french fries or baked potato. Loaded baked potato add 1.25.

Little Italy

12 and under only
Beef Ravioli
Meat sauce 7.50
Alfredo 9
Cheese Pizza 7.25
Add additional toppings to kids pizza 40 cents per topping.
Cheese Tortellini
Meat sauce 7.50
Alfredo 9
Fettucini Noodles
Meat sauce 6.25
Alfredo 7.25
Meat Tortellini
Meat sauce 7.50
Alfredo 9
Spaghetti Noodles
Meat sauce 6.25
Alfredo 7.25

Desserts

Chocolate Confusion Cake

6.75

Cannoli

5

Italian Cream Cheesecake

5.75

Black & White Mousse Cake
A buttery Oreo crumb crust filled with a layer of chocolate and vanilla mousse.

6.75

New!
Salted Caramel Cheesecake

6.75

Limoncello

6

Tiramisu

5.75

Spumoni Bomba
Strawberry, pistachio, and chocolate gelato, all coated in a chocolate shell.

6

Alcoholic Beverages

21 and older only

Draft Beer

Amber Rock
Gumball Head
Blue Moon
Michelob Ultra
Busch Light
Modelo Draft
Quaffon Strawberry Blonde
Peroni Italian Lager
Stella Artois

Bottled Beer

Bud Light
Budweiser
Busch Light
Coors Light
Michelob Ultra
Miller Light
Yuengling

Wine

White Wines
Chardonnay
Moscato Castello (Italy) *sweet
Moscato D'asti Misa Docea (Italy) * sweet
Pinot Grigio
Riesling
White Zinfandel
Red Wines
Cabernet Sauvignon
Chianti
Malavasia San Guilio (Italy) *sweet
Merlot
Pinot Noir
Sangria

Cocktails

Amaretto Sour
Bahama Mama
Blue Long Island
Classic Margarita
Also available in strawberry, mango, and peach
Dirty Martini
Georgia Peach Martini
Lemon Drop Martini
Long Island Ice Tea
Old Fashion
Pink Bikini
Strawberry Daiquiri
Come & Eat
Start an Order
Downtown Vincennes, Indiana

Procopio's

Order Now